Ben Lilly, 1856-1936, portrayed by Robert Boyle

Sgt. Leonidas Lytle, 1846-1924, portrayed by Dale Lane

Agnes Mary Kennon, 1835-1876, portrayed by Kari Lane

James Woodward, 1853-1926, portrayed by Dennis Murati

Mary Richard Casey 1847-1900, portrayed by Linda Bluestone

Catherine McCarty-Antrim, 1829-1874, portrayed by The Rev. Tara Soughers

James Metcalf, 1824-1910, portrayed by Douglas Dinwiddie

Forrest Norrel, 1833-1884, portrayed by the Rev. Earseye Ross

John Bullard, 1841-1871, portrayed by Donnie Koebel

Jennie Culver, 1846-1871, portrayed by Kris Isom.

James Lucas, 1826-1900, portrayed by George Carr

Minerva T. Carrillo, 1925-1988, portrayed by a descendant, Ana Tolhurst

Cornelias Cousland, 1856-1927, portrayed by James Charleston

Bessie Harper, 1855-1929, portrayed by Liz Mikols

"Bobby" Jackson, 1918-1969, portrayed by Tom Hester

W.D. Murray, 1870-1962, portrayed by John Bell, M.D.

John Ball, 1825-1903, portrayed by Bruce Tolhurst

Nat Straw, 1856-1941, portrayed by Tim Turner

Joseph Lafferr, 1841-1864, portrayed by Raul S. Turrieta, Jr.